Why did dutch leave arthur When John asks Dutch why he’s there, he replies, “Same reason as you, I suppose. Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Arthur pretty much hated Dutch towards the end because he didn't care about John and he started to make plans to get John, Abigail and Jack out. Maybe he finally realized that but we, the players and John just didn’t know. Because he’s getting fed up with Dutch’s bullshit about honour, decency, being better than society, taking in and helping waifs and strays etc. Aug 17, 2020 · One of Dutch Van der Linde’s fatal mistakes in Red Dead Redemption 2 is trusting Micah Bell for so long. However, when Arthur confessed about Micah betraying the gang, Dutch was left speechless and dismissed Arthur’s confession. Nov 10, 2023 · When did Dutch Van Der Linde begin to turn against Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2? Was there any signs?Join the discord here:https://discord. But Dutch is a broken man by the time we see him turn on them, this is not the same man as the beginning of the story. Arthur’s declining relations with Dutch were exacerbated by the growing bond between Micah and Dutch. Dutch considers what Arthur says to mean that John wants himself and his family to leave and he's trying to get Arthur to push Dutch into letting it, like he's the one pulling Arthur's strings. you got a point there. This is how the gang has lived their entire lives. He gave his life to save Arthur. Dutch is already Dutch, Hosea's death only contributed to Dutch's decline, which had been happening without such drastic outside factors anyway. After Hosea's death, the botched Saint Denis heist, and Arthur seeing Dutch's increasing ruthlessness. This is chapter 1! Jul 14, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Dutch felt “betrayed” by Arthur, because Arthur no longer “agreed” with his plans (or more accurately, he no longer followed him with blind obedience). At first it seems like a legitimate question, but this is probably the first time Arthur has ever done so much as that regarding Dutch’s behavior. Once you consider how Arthur told dutch constantly that micah was a problem and dutch disregarded those claims even when Arthur was healthy at the start of the game, it all falls apart. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son. The psychological change that occurred was enough to drive even Bill and Javier away. Although, Dutch didn’t apologize to Arthur eventhough he clearly wanted to because it was so easy for him to side with Micah because Arthur was dying. If Arthur's disloyalty really bothered dutch were he found leave both john and arthur to die why just kill em. com/ChrisZanarBecome my Patreon: https://www. Plus, he sees Arthur is already like 3 breaths away from dying on his own. Dutch never actually cared about money, and Arthur if he has high honor, he's too shocked by what Dutch did, but with low honor Arthur is just so disgruntled by everything at that point, the gold was the last thing on his mind. Arthur says, "I can't help feeling we would have been better running off someplace else". while the rest were either way dumber than Arthur (think Bill) or much younger and still in awe of Dutch. Then, just as John sought to do, Dutch shoots Micah allowing John to finish him off as he leaves John and Sadie alone. As Arthur lay dying and Dutch has his foot on Arthur's shooting hand, Arthur tells him "I gave you everything I had. Why would Dutch care if he were really that bitter about John leaving his family, I think Dutch’s distaste for John comes partly from his independence he finds later in the game and John’s opposition to Micah. throughout the story its called back on that Dutch hides a second pile of camp funds outside of camp, and in the last chapter you find out that its actually right near camp inside the cave (another show of dutch being batshit crazy now, the money being so close to camp. Was because Dutch still cared for them in away or was he trying make it realistic so it would raise any attention Because she didn’t need to be killed and wasn’t that much of a threat. The meet up spot for Dutch and Arthur wouldn't have been where Dutch and Colm met. I'm pretty sure that Dutch and Micah both came up a different path than Arthur and John at the end. And Arthur was known for going off doing his thing, so there was really no reason for him to immediately think that something bad had happened. This resurfaces later as the gang is dealing with Angelo Bronte, where Dutch viciously murders him before feeding his body to an alligator in a display of brutality that shocks Meanwhile Arthur once had a son that he now no longer had the chance to be a father to because he was killed. As Arthur lays dying, pleading with Dutch to see that Micah is a rat, his former mentor begins to piece it all together. Also, unless Arthur was out for a loooooooong ass time, all of it happened in one day. Nov 22, 2023 · Why did Dutch shoot Micah and leave? Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son. I agree he kind of did a 180 in chapter 6 though. So towards the end of the gang’s run, Dutch had completely forgotten about the gangs ideals and only started caring about his well being, which is why he abandoned John and Arthur. and 2. The REAL reason why is that Arthur feels like John got special treatment from Dutch because abandoning the gang is a form of being a traitor. although i’m not sure or dutch would kill arthur. Nov 16, 2024 · Yeah because Arthur didn't exist as a narrative point at the time, he was retroactively made important to John's character so it feels really awkward when 1 now exists but Arthur is never mentioned by anybody or even in any capacity. Not need to kill Arthur himself That situation is more about Dutch leaving for himself, and leaving Micah and Arthur to finish their dispute. Though Arthur and John were on the right side, but Arthur was dying so maybe Bill and Javier felt they had no choice Though Bill & Javier were complete jerks to Arthur when they got to Beaver Hollow camp. Why did dutch van der linde shoot micah bell in red dead redemption 2? Did dutch avange arthur morgan by killing micah? was dutch able to redeem himself by t It’s my understanding that Dutch didn’t stick with Micah after Arthur’s death and was only there at the epilogue to kill Micah. He expresses his discontent over Cleet dutch definitely couldnt kill his sons by his own hands, the reason the ending hit so hard to me is that he was so willing to leave them to die despite raising them up, but i realised afterwards thats the way it had to be to really understand how far gone dutch was, while john and arthur were opposing him near the end giving him less reason to save them on top of being just. He tried. As Micah shouts for Dutch to run, Dutch, for the first time I've ever seen, is speechless. The final fight. S. In the end reality caught up to him and when Hosea and Arthur died he went in full denial mode and went on a crime spree. Why did Dutch abandon John? ‘ He had grown more paranoid and manic after Hosea’s death and the botched Saint Denis robbery, with Arthur even beginning to … I mean I kind of get that Dutch cared about Arthur deeply at one point, but he does in fact leave him to die during the mission when you rush the oil fields. However, he was speechless upon hearing and dismissing Arthur's confession about Micah on ratting out on the gang. (RDR2 4) After Arthur's fight with Micah in the Red Dead Redemption mission, why didn't Dutch decided to kill Arthur? Because with how bad things are between him and Arthur, he could've decided to have his gun pointed at him, say something like "I should killed you a long time ago because you betrayed me and you wouldn't have faith in me", then kill him. Probably because he felt guilty and was mentally worn down at that point. However, Dutch was going to kill Micah in the Epilogue when John messed it up. true. Then a few missions later when they rob the Cornwall train Dutch blames Arthur for the TNT not going off and Arthur straight up says to Dutch “you’re pathetic”. It was like a hesitance. Oct 14, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Jul 10, 2023 · Why did Dutch shoot Micah? However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. But Dutch never seemed to love Micah, just his ideas. But being stuck in an outdated form of life is what defines both Dutch and Arthur. if he really thought arthur wasn’t right and he is a rat, he would’ve killed him Nov 4, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Nov 4, 2024 · Why did Dutch like Micah so much? Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. I did". At that point, Dutch was the big wanted fish. However, he was speechless upon hearing and dismissing Arthur’s confession about Micah on ratting out on the gang. At least thats how it seems to me He basically emotionally abuses Arthur from the get go, accusing him of disloyalty when Arthur even asks about the Blackwater job that Dutch personally fucked up, both in ditching the lead that hosea and Arthur had and following Micah instead, to then blowing that girl's head off on the ferry. There is no end game for Dutch, which is why he comes up with his “master plans” which involve robberies and heists. yk batshit If Arthur and John still followed along then they didn’t betray him. There are no spaces between the exclamation marks and the spoiler text. Dec 10, 2023 · Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Only Eagle Flies showing up prevents Arthurs death. Killing Micah was an act of projection, not an act of redemption. You seen how it changed Dutch when Hosea died? Add Arthur dying, and John leaving for good. The duo formed the Van der Linde gang together. it looked like they tried to kill them. These are the relationships Dutch van der Linde has had prior to and throughout the events of Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2. Worse, Dutch left him to die and I believe, Arthur tried to convince himself that Dutch didn't see him or was occupied. Micah easily could’ve made up the wayward plan for Colm to capture Arthur to lure in Dutch, and then just go behind Colm’s back and steer Dutch back home with “he’s probably just wandering around Dutch, you know how he is,” except Arthur always, always, does a head count and make sure everybody gets home safe back to camp after a mission My Last Boy is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. The Jun 16, 2024 · Why did Dutch walk away from Arthur? Micah asks Dutch to come with him and take the money, but Dutch, shocked over the fact that he brought his gang to ruin and no longer wishing to associate himself with either man, simply walks away without a word, signifying the end of the Van der Linde gang. Like all brothers they fought from time to time. Dutch grew suspicious that Arthur was the snake in the group and the bond between him and Arthur wavered. So, I recently did a replay on RDR2 and was just thinking. Allegedly after you get knocked out, Colm stalls and makes small talk before abruptly leaving. Red Dead Redemption 2 My Last Boy mission full gameplay - Dutch, Arthur, Eagle Flies, Charles, and the Gang attack Factory. Sep 19, 2023 · Dutch quickly picked up on Arthur’s doubting and, in response, began to question Arthur’s loyalty, comparing his doubting to John, who he began losing trust in. Arthur never stopped loving Dutch. He already didn’t trust him. Also Arthir was bold when questioning Dutchs desecions but it was ovbious that Arthur really just cared about Dutch and the gang, when Hosea questioned Dutch he When Dutch is sitting in a chair looking out over the swamp and is going over chess moves to himself. I didn’t understand why Dutch was still with Micah anyways at that point. Jul 29, 2024 · Did Dutch regret leaving Arthur? Did Dutch regret betraying Arthur? It’s never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. The last thing Arthur wanted before he died was to save Dutch. When Arthur insists he let the women go he snaps, assuming that Arthhur is either trying to usurp the gang or remove his support, either way these are surely things Micah had been whispering in his ear. Where does Charles go after RDR2? He later gives his farewells to the Marston family, Uncle, and Sadie as he leaves the ranch. It is possible to miss, but it clarifies why he would choose Dutch over Arthur. Micah and Dutch wait for you, but since odriscols took all your stuff and horse Dutch just assumes you ran off while nothing was I’d say Dutch started taking favor in Micah when Arthur pressed Dutch about the lady in guarma. Self-preservation would dictate staying away from Dutch, Micah and the gang. Why did Dutch trust Micah instead of Arthur? That was why he chose somewhere so far, that no one has a clue of ("Tahitians, I guess" scene). If R* didn’t do this intentionally, then they wouldn’t have Arthur mention Dutch getting knocked in the head. But something that I never undestood, was why the gang left Arthur in the boat in the final of Chapter 4? Funny how Arthur did not want to go bail Micah out of jail yet he did because dutch asked him too, yet Arthur was captured because of Micah and not Micah nor Dutch come to save him. But Dutch sided with Micah anyway at the time. It was never about the money with Dutch, hence why he left it behind. In a Mexican standoff, Dutch shoots Micah, letting John finish him off, before leaving. Arthur's final act on this earth was not helping John, going for money, or even fighting Micah. And they are very biased to the point they come up with anything to excuse Arthur. Why does Dutch hate John? Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur's intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Dutch knew Arthur was sick and the money was no good for him at this point. Feb 20, 2024 · Why did Dutch leave Arthur? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Arthur approaches and talks with him. Maybe he wanted to take over Micah's gang as replacement like he did with the natives in RDR1, who knows? Jul 17, 2023 · Arthur convinces Dutch to abandon Micah and leave. 41 votes, 40 comments. It's really that simple. Yeah, but Lenny and Arthur didn’t hit their heads. Dutch trusted micah, micah was a slime and earned it taking advantage of dutch's predatory nature by appearing to be a loyal servant, which dutch appreciated. ' When John asks Dutch what he's doing there, Dutch says "same as you, I suppose". That's when he realizes what he has done. To me, him killing Arthur actually makes less sense. So Dutch betrayed Arthur because Arthur didn’t think Dutch should leave a member of what he calls their “family” behind to hang? The true reason that Dutch is unaware of Arthur's missing or believes Arthur's absence is no biggie is the other companion on this job, Micah, convinces Dutch to return to camp without Arthur. It's safe to say that he did not trust Micah either. gg/qzwCD This I feel like is wrong. Dutch loves chaos, point and simple. Which means Dutch was probably there to kill Micah and take the money and run. Money was the motivation for the rest of the gang, and Dutch knew that. Micah's constant whispering in his ear and Arthur's constant and direct rebuffs and doubts led Dutch to spiral our of control into paranoia. He didn't need Arthur's gun when he (Dutch) had half a dozen others loyal to him. If the player has high honor, Arthur succumbs to his injuries and disease, dying peacefully while watching the sunrise; with low honor, Micah executes him. Dutch already thought either John or Abigail (or both) had betrayed him during the Saint Denis bank robbery, and if John could betray him then Arthur would as well. They don't like modern civilization, so why exactly didn't they go to let's say Jul 7, 2022 · Why did Dutch leave John? After John is captured and sent to prison, Dutch does not prioritize his rescue, even scolding Arthur for doing so. Dutch also left Arthur to die in the Cornwall factory and did not attempt to help him. ) at the very end of the last chapter, when you can choose to Which also makes you realize why Arthur Morgan is named such and why he’s Welsh. Going to find Arthur meant leaving the meeting. I mean think about what you said. John turns up and also confronts Dutch about leaving him for Jun 22, 2023 · Why did Dutch leave John behind? Later, during the final heist, Dutch leaves John behind, likely due to his belief John has become disloyal. But why didn't Bill and Javier stick with Dutch? They chose to side with Dutch and Micah instead of Arthur and John. I think Dutch was a broken man after losing Arthur and the gang. Deep down, he knew Arthur was right. May 16, 2024 · John, like Arthur, becomes increasingly wary of Dutch’s growing paranoia and recklessness; protective of John’s family, Arthur warns him to leave the gang when the time is right. If he left Arthur he would, 1. If Dutch really stayed with Micah during that time, don't you think he would've been heard of as well. in the other version micah just wants arthur to die slowly and painfully. Plus Micah kept making noise, during the 8 year gap. At that moment, I think Dutch realized just what he'd done. There was also a little rivalry over who was Dutch's favorite. Why did he bristle when Arthur insisted he let them go? Dutch didn't even like them and seemed privately determined to turn the gang into a band of outlaw soldiers as opposed to keeping a family structure (hence the addition of micah's old buddies). Reply reply There is a line of dialogue from Javier on a side mission, something about loyalty being everything. Why did Dutch shoot the girl in Blackwater? What motivated Dutch to shoot McCourt is unknown. Because that makes Dutch a hypocrite (again). Hosea’s relationship with Dutch was tested by their disagreements over how to make money, as Hosea’s preference for non-violence, such as Dutch ignoring Ms. He already agreed to team back up with Micah, and even left the money afterwards. In the end though. ) If Dutch had any logical reason to doubt Arthur apart from his paranoia and need to control and manipulate, he could easily spin the situation to have Arthur killed by Bill, Micah or Javier who were a lot more loyal, a bit more dense and in Micah’s case more trigger happy. Arthur began to wonder if Dutch was the man who he thought he was, and he began to doubt in Dutch and his supposed ideals. Feb 20, 2024 · Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). They fled along with Dutch, Micah and the others while taking different paths. Arthur and Charles talk about it end of Chapter 2. Dec 8, 2023 · Dutch realizes what Arthur is saying is true and backs away, leaving Micah on the hillside. He left the money because it was no longer any use for him. Nov 7, 2024 · Analyzing Dutch’s Motivations. And it suits Micah's interest that either Arthur gets killed unnoticed or the whole Dutch gang gets lured into the Pinkerton's trap later on. Definitely, If Micah hadn't manipulated Dutch so badly, Then when Arthur returns to camp and tells Dutch how Micah's been working as a rat. May 1, 2022 · Even early on, when Javier mentions that Dutch shot a girl during a robbery, it's clear that Dutch has an unnecessarily violent side that Arthur doesn't want to believe. But the main part why Arthur is angry at John in the beginning, is that John ditched the gang for over a year, some time prior to the game, after Jack was born, which Arthur felt massively betrayed by. Aug 17, 2023 · Why did Dutch betray John and Arthur? Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2 He repeatedly tells Arthur and others that they have to stick to his plan in order to survive, even as circumstances continue to worsen around them. This raises the question of why the Dutch was so loyal to him in the first place, considering he’d known him for a shorter amount of time than many of the other members of the Van der Linde gang, many of which clearly had a problem with Micah. He didn’t argue, he didn’t put up a fight, nor did he tried to shoot him. By killing Micah, he can spend the rest of his Your story makes sense for the most part except for Dutch’s insistence on saving John in the first chapter of the game. I’d like to hear everyone’s opinions on why Dutch had to hide the loot he got from the Blackwater massacre and why he didn’t want to, or couldn’t just bring it with them to the mountains. dutch, micah, joe, cleet, bill, and javier, were chasing john and arthur when they were escaping. Dutch runs from problems rather than face them head on, and the realization that Arthur was right all along means that Dutch was wrong all along and that’s something he (Dutch) doesn’t want to face. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutch’s plans. in the high honor endings micah is sadistic: leaving arthur to slowly die or be caught by the pinkertons. He was blind to Arthur’s warnings about Micah’s true nature and chose to trust Micah instead. Delusional, and unable to come to terms with the world changing, he made the choice to actually leave too late. Dutch later left John for dead during a botched train robbery, though It really felt like Dutch didn't like them at all. Dec 20, 2020 · Dutch responds by shooting Micah, giving John the chance to pump him full of lead. Dutch realizes what Arthur is saying is true and backs away, leaving Micah on the hillside. However, if you try to see Dutch's PoV, it isn't that easy. And Arthur knows how Dutch feels about traitors but Dutch still took him back which confuses Arthur. Dutch loves Arthur. Dutch’s loves John in a way. While Dutch was losing it before then, he was able to keep his cool. Well Micah has no real motivation to kill Arthur, I mean sure Arthur accused him of being a rat, but it clearly didn't affect anything since Dutch didn't buy it. This may be why Dutch eventually has delusions that caused him to leave John and Arthur for dead when they were in danger. Just a shower thought since i kinda love Dutch but also hate him. Their struggle against "civilization. Did Dutch regret leaving Arthur? It’s unclear if Dutch regretted leaving Arthur. He wanted John and Arthur killed because he did not trust them. This is why he wants to leave John in prison. But Micah was supporting his plan to escape with the money, while Arthur endangered that plan at that point. Arthur proved him wrong, Micah was a rat, and Dutch was left speechless. He stammers and steps back off of Arthur, looking at him in disbelief. Actually, I would also wager that Arthur might've had some feelings for Abigail way back. Why wasn t Arthur in Blackwater? Arthur wasn’t present for the heist because he was pulling a con with Hosea elsewhere, and doesn’t hear the details until after the fact. Bill makes little sense, but he always wanted to be a leader. As of why he didn't take the money after killing Micah is beyond me. He wrote that Abigail would've made him a fine wife so Arthur likely also is mad that John would leave a good woman like Abigail. Dutch doesn’t even care about the $20,000 he left in the cabin. He knew he was fucked but he was gonna to put one thing right. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it’s hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out. Why didn’t he kill Dutch or Micah then? Why did he sit passively for so long until the end of chapter 6. Dutch believed Arthur on the mountain that's why he walked away from Micah. One primary reason is Dutch’s deteriorating state of mind and growing greed as the story progresses. so in one version micah's so pissed at arthur he needs to kill him himself to feel better. and continued his outlaw run Edited December 24, 2019 by GroveStGTAV Armerius and Deadman2112 Oct 31, 2018 · Informative showcase video off the cutscenes where Dutch van der Linde betrayed John Marston, and the reason why Dutch van der Linde, Bill Williamson and Jav When Arthur told him that he gave him all he had, that broke Dutch’s ego. Arthur insisted John gets let out of the gang before they rob the train. Jan 20, 2024 · Why did Dutch believe Micah instead of Arthur? Dutch believed Micah instead of Arthur because he saw Micah as more loyal to him and the gang. He’s also known Dutch for 20 years. Dutch and the gang then accompany Eagle Flies into battle against the U. “Dutch never did wrong by Arthur until after Arthur went behind his back and got John outta prison”. Against his father, Chief Rains Fall's wishes. Arthur also isn't shy in showing he doesn't like how Dutch is handling things and repeatedly talks about how 'our luck has turned, and it ain't turning back. Plus Arthur's wife & child were killed and was the worst pain he'd ever felt in his life. No idea why he'd finally split. Jul 31, 2023 · Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). He probably just left after awhile. I think its a way for Dutch trying to redeem himself, at least for now, for what he did 8 years ago (listening to Micah and not Arthur) that resulted to the gang's downfall. I believe Dutch knew he was 100% wrong after looking into Arthur’s dying eyes. In 1907, Dutch meets with Micah before John and Sadie attack Micah’s new gang. It looks like this: >!spoiler text!<. Ever since that situation Arthur started to see Dutch’s true colors and was started disagreeing with him every other mission and Dutch being the narcissist he is started to lose the relationship with Arthur and the rest is history. See full list on gamerant. Javier doubted Dutch towards the end and was even hesitant to aim at Arthur. Dutch didn't pick either path when offered to run away with Micah. But after the crash, he started acting out. Being the dreamer who trusts his intuition that Dutch is, (and having seen all the death before that, especially Hosea's) he convinced himself that during those moments Arthur and John needed to die for the new chapter of Aug 20, 2023 · Why did Dutch let Arthur die? Micah killed Arthur because in the eyes of Dutch and the rest of the gang members who sided with him, he was seen as a traitor. This would make Dutch after Arthur’s death a much more likeable and reasonable character. Even more so when Hosea was killed. after finishing the game some days ago (I cried, poor horse poor Awtha) I just could not figure out why the gang didn't flee to the west after the Blackwater score went wrong so horribly. Arthur and John were both practically raised as children to Dutch . I think this is proven beyond doubt in how Arthur spends the last of his energy. Why did Dutch leave Arthur and Micah? In the end, Dutch left because he had nothing else to use against Scarface. " Dutch admits he's wrong plenty of times - like in a camp convo where he confesses his mistake at Blackwater to Arthur and Sep 29, 2021 · Near the end of the game. (half the gang joined it having pointed a gun at Dutch or trying to rob him - the fact he kills her is a massive turn around). Apr 14, 2021 · Dutch would later leave Arthur to die at the hands of the soldiers hot on the gang's tail, though Arthur managed to escape. In the end, Dutch leaving the Blackwater money behind was him finally giving up, and apologizing to John and Arthur for not believing them over Micah. Only lose a traitor. Does John have a happy Aug 17, 2020 · One of Dutch Van der Linde’s fatal mistakes in Red Dead Redemption 2 is trusting Micah Bell for so long. Dutch knew he was wrong, but his ego wouldn’t allow him to admit it, so he left him there. Jul 16, 2023 · Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). So combine the poison words of Micah with the questioning nature of Arthur and Dutch's own insecurities, anxiety, and distrust and so when Arthur "insists" he lets John and his family go, you can see why it would really irk Dutch that Arthur, the man who has questioned his plans from the beginning (of the game), would insist he let John (the But seeing how Dutch reacted when Jack was kidnapped, I think is unlikely that Dutch would abandon his son, specially when the ones that took Arthur where the O'Driscoll. After So Arthur takes Jack fishing and Agent Milton and Ross show up to ask Arthur to turn over Dutch Of course Arthur claims to have not seen Dutch in months but why did the agents leave Arthur alone? Milton tells Arthur that he has a bounty of $5000 on his head, and they had the upper hand in the situation Ross had a shotgun pointed at Arthur and Arthur saw shit going sideways since like chapter 2. Secretly, Dutch wanted his plans to go wrong, and he became careless. Dutch kind of wanted Arthur out of his hair near the end of the game. It is easier for Dutch to blame Micah for what he did to Arthur and the gang than to admit that he was the one who betrayed his most loyal friends. If you return to camp and just sit still for a while, Dutch will come up to you and explain what he thought happened. ly/2oVO5GZFollow me on Twitter: https://twitter. Dutch responds, "But, the game ain't over, Arthur". Later on in the mission after Arthur and John get the dynamite and regroup with Dutch and the gang outside of Saint Denis, Dutch goes over the plan and Now Dutch, losing 3 of his most loyal family members and being allowed to be fooled by Micah drove him over the edge. Several interpretations have been proposed to explain Dutch’s decision to shoot Micah: Realization of Betrayal: Some suggest that Dutch finally acknowledges Micah’s betrayal and his role in the gang’s downfall. Why did Dutch side with Micah instead of Arthur? Because Micah told Dutch what he wanted to hear. Jun 27, 2024 · Did Dutch know Micah was a rat? Red Dead Redemption 2. The truth is Dutch loved Arthur and John, they were as his sons. Exactly, Dutch abandoned Micah and dropped off the face of the earth for 8 years. German family saves Arthur. So he left the money to John, Charles, and Sadie since those three were the ones who believed and followed Arthur. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Dutch did and it’s pointed out in dialogue. i think the money that theyre referring to is THE camp money. Arthur meets Dutch outside of his tent, where there is a small gathering. May 23, 2024 · Dutch intervenes in a fight between Arthur and Micah, and Arthur convinces him to abandon Micah and leave. Dutch and Micah should have been killed from the get go And why did he even take Dutch’s orders from the beginning of chapter 6. How old is Arthur Morgan? Arthur Morgan is 36. Oct 26, 2018 · Dutch either doesn’t believe Arthur, or doesn’t want to, knowing that regardless of the truth, Micah is all Dutch has left now. Now, years later, Dutch Van Der Linde arrives at Micah’s wanting to kill him. He becomes increasingly obsessed with power and wealth, causing him to lose sight of the gang’s original … My favourite detail in this game’s writing is actually the way they contrast Arthur and Dutch’s brands of charisma: Arthur doesn’t believe he’s particularly charming, or go out of his way to make any pretense - he just improvises quips and has a naturally easygoing demeanour when he’s relaxed. Feb 24, 2024 · Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions throughout the game and believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money. Eagle Flies rides into Beaver Hollow to rally a war party for the final raid on Cornwall Kerosene & Tar. And this causes a problem for Dutch as arthur is helping people John and other leave the gang. But when Arthur breaks him out, going against Dutch's orders, he starts to think you might be picking Johns side, the traitor's side. Dutch and Hosea were best friends for more than two decades. His tone really changed even though Arthur didn't do all much wrong. Some of the earliest Arthurian literature and poems were written in Welsh. At the end, when Dutch is standing over Arthur, unable to speak. Nov 21, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Yes, but I think there's an important difference. Jun 27, 2024 · Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). All because Dutch left Arthur behind when he could have helped him. Dutch would have ended Micah right there, The gang would have got away with the money from the train robbery, And would have plenty enough money to get to Tahiti. Army. By killing Micah, Dutch seeks a form of redemption for his earlier failures. Why fleeing to the east, where civilization is already more developed. Dutch say's he's working it all out, once and for all. Even though Arthur and the people who sided with him (Sadie, Charles, John, Susan) were morally right as the gang was deteriorating, Micah painted them as traitors and Dutch believed as such. Why did Arthur have to leave all his money behind, despite Ms Grimshaw being able to collect all of his other items? Yes, people always judge Dutch through Arthur and John's PoV. He killed him both times cuz he was angry that dutch left so he couldn’t manipulate dutch anymore for all the money. He'd rather delude himself into thinking Arthur died intentionally sacrificing himself and buying time for Dutch to escape than the truth; that Dutch took the opportunity to throw Arthur to the wolves to save himself. Arthur was 'napped during the day, woke up and escaped in the evening. Arthur had more "rank" in the gang as one of the oldest members and basically Dutch/Hosea's right hand man, so he was in a unique position to start questioning Dutch's B. Grimshaw's death is shocking but at that point it is sadly not out of character. Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Aug 29, 2023 · Why did Dutch betray Arthur and John? Why does Dutch leave John the money? Following an encounter with John and Sadie, however, Dutch has a change of heart. Is Abigail the rat in RDR2? Hi! It looks like you did not use the spoiler syntax correctly. This not only sets up the events of the original Red Dead Redemption but also closes the door on the possibility of healing their friendship. Dutch could be viewed as a false king and bring to mind William the Bastard, the Norman conqueror who took over the British Isles & styled themselves King of England. but when dutch saw arthur on the mountain he didn’t kill him tho. Mar 1, 2020 · So at the end of the game Dutch finds Micah and Arthur fighting together then just leaves them both, not only Arthur but Micah too, then towards the end of the prologue he is seen with Micah, even though he knew that Micah was spying on him and that he "left" him at the end of the game, is it just Rockstar being lazy or is there genuine reasoning behind this He left him alive in the camp because he knows arthur is dying so he just goes to get the money and on the mountain it was cuz he was injured and he knew he couldn’t outrun the pinkertons. Especially since in the ending I got Micah and ditch leave in separate directions as Arthur is dying, seeming to show Dutch leaving him, but nah, they still together John asks Dutch what he’s doing there and Dutch says “Same as you I suppose”. ” (Probably not the exact quote, but somewhere along those lines. I feel like shooting Micah was the nail in the coffin for him. But there must have been countless times over the years in which the other gang members saved Dutch’s neck, so it doesn’t exactly explain why he felt more inclined to trust Micah over everyone else. Jan 11, 2019 · Dutch did the same thing, at the end, killed micah(for arthur) and left all money for john. there's no immediate blood lust in micah just a need to see arthur suffer. Like it pisses me off. People say Hosea kept Dutch in check, but even as far as the game's FIRST CHAPTER, we witness Dutch ignoring Hosea's warnings and going ahead with his own plan (Cornwall train robbery). They have a soft spot for John as the protagonist of RDR1 and for Arthur as RDR2 protagonist. When Arthur, John and Bill are taking Kieran to Six Point Cabin in Chapter 2 to kill O’Driscolls, John says to Kieran that the difference between the O’Driscolls and the Van Der Linde gang is that the O’Driscolls are out to survive but that Dutch’s Boys are out to live. Nov 19, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Subscribe http://bit. As he says plain in his journal: Jun 17, 2024 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Or maybe Dutch just flat out told them to go away. Nov 4, 2023 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. The only reason Arthur survived is because Eagle Flies saved him, but got shot himself and ultimately died from his wounds. Later, during the final heist, Dutch leaves John behind, likely due to his belief John has become disloyal . ly/2oUkw8nSupport me/Donate: http://bit. com Dutch clearly knew Micah was wrong on the mountain where Arthur died, yet he did nothing. Jun 29, 2024 · Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Dutch’s betrayal of Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2 can be attributed to a combination of factors. And Colm isn't going to hang around because he knows either, a, his men succeeded or, b, his men didn't and sticking around would be dangerous. What if Dutch left John "for dead" was Dutch's way of letting John go and to protect him from Micah and the gang + the Pinkertons. I do believe that Dutch did originally want what was best for the gang and not for himself, but as the gang grew, so did his ego. agxs opspl dej xypszbo hfmolk bqahmf ihyasv bbzxshjw ebhxgn pgnm